Americans, Cheryl Cole will be a Uk judge for american idol, your opinion?

Well Im from england and I watched her on the X Factor and she really doesnt have that much talent to be honest with you. When she was in Girls Aloud, I not ONCE looked at her. She was nothing secial, more of a back up singer. I didnt even know who she was until X Factor so yes you are right S.C saw her looks and made her famous. Seriously, shes only famous for the X factor role. Only because of that she managed to release her own album and become a "style icon". If it wasnt for that, im sure she would be nothing more that a "backup singer". And to answer your question, I dont think its fair no. I think you can get much much much better and more professional singers to judge on american x factor because shes just not great. She bum licks simon cowells *** all the time.